Onion PK All articles
Opinion

Hollywood Finally Casts Pakistani Characters. Now Let Them Be People.

Onion PK
Hollywood Finally Casts Pakistani Characters. Now Let Them Be People.

Photo: Sam Shaw, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Hollywood has finally noticed that South Asia is not a monolith. In 2026, American film and TV are crowded with South Asian faces in ways that would have felt radical a decade ago. There are South Asian doctors, South Asian tech founders, South Asian love interests, and South Asian villains with better cheekbones than accents. Progress, sort of.

But if you are Pakistani-American and you watch closely, you notice something. The casting call may be open, but the script is still narrow. Pakistani characters keep landing in the same four lanes: the doctor with a stethoscope and a tragic backstory, the taxi driver with wisdom, the tech genius who can hack anything, or the villain with a vague accent and a grudge. These are not characters. They are costumes.

The Four Lanes

Let’s start with the doctor. It is a real profession, and Pakistani-Americans are proud of it. But on screen, the Pakistani doctor is often a plot device—someone to deliver bad news, explain a diagnosis, or look tired in a hospital hallway. The audience learns nothing about the person. We do not see their family, their humor, their politics, or the fact that they might be terrible at cooking.

The taxi driver is worse. He is usually a philosopher with a heart of gold, dispensing life advice to the white protagonist. He has no last name, no interior life, and no reason to be in the scene except to make the hero feel something. It is a compliment and an erasure at the same time.

The tech genius is the new model minority. He or she is brilliant, awkward, and conveniently available to solve the plot. The character’s Pakistani-ness is a costume detail—a name, a lunchbox, a mother who calls too often. The tech genius never has a love story that is not a joke.

And then there is the villain. In 2026, the villain often has a Pakistani name and an accent that wanders between Karachi, London, and nowhere. The villain is not religious, not political, not specific. The villain is just brown enough to be scary and vague enough to avoid a diplomatic incident.

What Actors Are Being Asked to Do

I spoke with Pakistani-American actors and writers who described the same audition loops. Ayesha Khan, an actor based in Los Angeles, said she has been asked to read for 'a doctor, a lawyer, a terrorist, or a mom' in the same week. 'The mom is usually the same mom,' she said. 'She is either very strict or very sad. There is no in-between.'

Omar Raza, a writer who has worked on two network dramas, said the notes often start with good intentions. 'They want to be respectful,' he said. 'So they make the character a doctor and give them a line about how hard their parents worked. That is not a character. That is a press release.'

The problem is not that these roles exist. Doctors exist. Taxi drivers exist. Tech founders exist. Villains exist. The problem is that when those are the only lanes, the audience learns to see Pakistani people as functions rather than people.

The Boom Is Real—and Uneven

It would be unfair to ignore the gains. South Asian representation in American entertainment has grown significantly since the 2020s. Streaming platforms have invested in South Asian-led projects. Writers’ rooms are more diverse. Casting directors are more aware of colorism and stereotyping than they were even five years ago.

But Pakistani specificity often gets flattened into 'South Asian' or 'Middle Eastern' or 'brown.' That means Pakistani characters can be played by Indian actors, Bangladeshi actors, or anyone with the right complexion. This is not a problem in itself—actors should be able to play across backgrounds—but it becomes a problem when the writing does not know the difference. Pakistan is not India. Karachi is not Mumbai. The history, the humor, the food, the politics, the accents—they are different.

The Archetypes Audiences Are Ready For

The good news is that the audience is ahead of the industry. Pakistani-American viewers are not asking for perfection. They are asking for specificity. Here are a few character types that feel obvious and underexplored:

These are not exotic. They are ordinary. That is the point.

What Would Actually Change the Script

The fix is not more consultants. It is more writers in the room who know the difference between a Pakistani and a Bangladeshi, and who are willing to write characters who are not explaining themselves. It is casting directors who ask for specificity instead of 'brown.' It is directors who let actors improvise a line in Urdu without subtitles. It is stories that trust the audience to keep up.

Hollywood has opened the casting call. Now it needs to open the script. Pakistani characters are ready to be people—messy, funny, contradictory, and specific. The audience is ready. The question is whether the industry is brave enough to let them be.

All Articles

Related Articles

Yaar, Just Say Chalo: A Field Guide to the Words Your Desi Coworker Keeps Using

Yaar, Just Say Chalo: A Field Guide to the Words Your Desi Coworker Keeps Using

Cost Per Purchase Explained: The Ad Metric Pakistani-American Entrepreneurs Actually Need to Understand

Cost Per Purchase Explained: The Ad Metric Pakistani-American Entrepreneurs Actually Need to Understand

Two Phones, One Soul: The Hilarious Double Life of Pakistani-Americans on Group Chats

Two Phones, One Soul: The Hilarious Double Life of Pakistani-Americans on Group Chats